Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Solar Energy News .




NUKEWARS
Outside View: The nuclear deal with Iran
by Harlan Ullman
Washington (UPI) Dec 4, 2013


disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only

The Thanksgiving holiday and the consumer shopping frenzy over "Black Friday" last week temporarily captured U.S. headlines, obscuring for a brief spell the nuclear deal that, if consummated, will assure Iran won't develop nuclear weapons.

But, make no mistake, debate over the agreement signed by the P-5 Plus One, the European Union and Iran will fill tons of newsprint and hours of television airtime over the next six months as debate rages over the virtues and vices of this deal.

Yet, almost certain to be lacking is thoughtful consideration of unintended consequences that may arise whether the agreement succeeds or sinks and how to respond regardless of the outcome.

First, and defying the odds, assume the agreement leads to a verifiable end state that guarantees Iran doesn't and won't develop nuclear weapons. Such an outcome will be a great accomplishment raising expectations and even generating euphoria about re-integrating Iran into the international system and ending the prospect of military action in the region to deny and degrade Iran's nuclear capacity.

Further, success will create the prospect of other potential breakthroughs from finding resolution to the Syrian civil war to ultimately ending the Arab-Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

As trade and economic commerce build and the intrusion of social media into Iranian society grows, the prospect for Iran evolving into a more open and less hostile state must increase. The crumbling of the clerictocracy isn't inevitable but it may be more likely.

On the other hand, relief of sanctions could easily strengthen the current regime as economic depravation and thus reasons for popular unrest recede.

A stronger economy means a stronger Iran. And a stronger Iran won't be welcomed by Saudi Arabia. Even without nuclear weapons, Iran can pose a threat to the Sunni Arab states in the Persian Gulf "by other means," namely covert activity and terrorism.

While removal of a potential existential nuclear threat should make Israel more secure, the possibility that Iran could abandon or secretly circumvent the agreement will stoke concern and indeed paranoia by the right wing permanently distrustful of Iran.

The same distrust exists in the United States by those who will fear as the Soviet Union "cheated" during the Cold War despite signed nuclear reduction treaties, so, too, will Iran. Hence, what might be viewed as opportunity for bringing permanent peace and stability to the region will be limited by long standing suspicions and animosities.

If the agreement fails or breaks down, the Obama administration, pushed by Saudi Arabia, Israel and members of Congress, may have no alternative except to use military force against Iran's nuclear infrastructure.

Whether other states, including the "P-5 Plus One," would support or participate in military action is problematic. Surely, re-imposing and even strengthening the economic and financial embargoes would be a certainty. Iran would become more isolated internationally with repercussions that will affect the Syrian civil war through continued use of Hezbollah as a surrogate. Retaliation against Israel cannot be dismissed.

The most damaging unintended consequence of a failed agreement is to push the region into further violence, conflict and even a full-blown war.

On the other hand, should the agreement falter, en lieu of a Gulf War, a more innovative and imaginative strategy could emerge to protect allies and friends in the region.

The Soviet Union was a military superpower with tens of thousands of nuclear weapons and a huge army but it was contained and deterred. There is no reason that a similar strategy of containment and deterrence of Iran couldn't be recreated in the region including the stationing of more U.S. forces on the ground and at sea. Missile defense, building on the network already in place in the Persian Gulf with headquarters in Doha, Qatar, could be part of this strategic plan.

Obviously, it is impossible and implausible to envisage all the unintended consequences that might occur over the next six months as this nuclear agreement continues to unfold.

However, some of the more likely possibilities and contingencies should help condition strategic thinking and planning to deal with different outcomes, good and bad. Understanding that success or failure brings both new opportunities and risks is vital to this thinking.

No outcome will be entirely favorable or completely detrimental to the interests of those determined to prevent the proliferation of nuclear weapons in the gulf. The greater risk is failing to anticipate unintended consequences or preparing to deal with them.

Unfortunately, the mentality of "you are with or against us" in what tragically has become "zero sum" political pitched battles in the United States over virtually every issue, makes agility and sophistication in strategic thinking and planning elusive and indeed virtually extinct qualities.

(Harlan Ullman is senior adviser at the Atlantic Council in Washington and chairman of the Killowen Group, which advises leaders of business and government.)

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)

.


Related Links
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com
Learn about missile defense at SpaceWar.com
All about missiles at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








NUKEWARS
Iran judge condemns American to death for spying
Tehran (AFP) Jan 9, 2012
An Iranian judge sentenced a US-Iranian man to death for spying for the CIA, media reported Monday, exacerbating high tensions in the face of Western sanctions on the Islamic republic's nuclear programme. Amir Mirzai Hekmati, a 28-year-old former Marine born in the United States to an Iranian family, was "sentenced to death for cooperating with a hostile nation, membership of the CIA and try ... read more


NUKEWARS
Process holds promise for production of synthetic gasoline

Microbiologists reveal unexpected properties of methane-producing microbe

Direvo completes lab scale development of low cost lactic acid production

Scripps Oceanography Researchers Engineer Breakthrough for Biofuel Production

NUKEWARS
Droids dance, dogs nuzzle, humanoids speak at Madrid robot museum

Spanish scientists are designing a robot for inspecting tunnels

Penguin-inspired propulsion system

Artificial heart to pump human waste into future robots

NUKEWARS
Ethiopia spearheads green energy in sub-Saharan Africa

Small-Wind Power Market to Reach $3 Billion by 2020

Siemens achieves major step in type certification for 6MW Offshore Wind Turbine

IKEA invests in Canadian wind project

NUKEWARS
Sweden joins race for self-driving cars

Motorized bicycle wheel said to give 20 mph speed, range of 30 miles

Electric cars take 10% of new sales in Norway: official data

Carmakers rev up for return to Iran market

NUKEWARS
Turkey moots three-party talks over Iraq-Kurd oil row

Greenpeace activists held after crashing energy conference

Singapore ready to be LNG trading hub

Actor Bardem's mother protests Canaries oil-drilling

NUKEWARS
Npower layoffs reignite calls for Britain energy market reforms

Iran, Russia in talks on new Bushehr nuclear plant

World Bank says no money for nuclear power

Bomb blast near India nuclear plant kills six: police

NUKEWARS
India needs $2.1 trillion investment for energy: IEA

Rice U. study: It's not easy 'being green'

Founders of Envirofit Selected as Energy Innovators of the Year by The Economist

World's top carbon emitter China expands emissions trading

NUKEWARS
Researchers identify genetic fingerprints of endangered conifers

Lowering stand density reduces mortality of ponderosa pine stands

VTT introduces deforestation monitoring method for tropical regions

Philippines to plant more mangroves in wake of Typhoon Haiyan




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement