Solar Energy News  
Russia row shows NATO needs reality check: IISS

"NATO must not transform its expansion policy into a game of Russian roulette," Chipman said, blasting Georgia's actions in South Ossetia as "irresponsible". "A policy of NATO enlargement now, we believe, would be a strategic error. Normally when military alliances enlarge it is to gain strength themselves, it is not to assume new strategic liabilities."
by Staff Writers
London (AFP) Sept 18, 2008
NATO would be making a major strategic error trying to expand in the face of Russian anger, a respected international think tank said Thursday.

NATO must not play "Russian roulette" with the Kremlin as it considers how to respond to Moscow's "disproportionate" use of force in Georgia, said the London-based International Institute for Strategic Studies.

The IISS questioned whether the US-led alliance should "lock horns" with Russia, given its strategic need for support from Moscow in flashpoints such as Afghanistan and Iran.

Launching its "Strategic Survey 2008" annual review of global security, IISS chief John Chipman played down the risk of a new Cold War developing between the West and Russia.

"Neither side wants one and the stakes are too low to warrant one," he said.

However, the Georgia-Russia conflict does mark "the distinct end of the romantic phase of the post-Cold War order," he added.

"We are now entering an era... where international diplomatic activity will be more plural. America is unable now to shape the international agenda alone and needs international partners."

NATO reaffirmed its pledge of eventual membership for Georgia and Ukraine after the Russia-Georgia conflict last month.

"NATO must not transform its expansion policy into a game of Russian roulette," Chipman said, blasting Georgia's actions in South Ossetia as "irresponsible".

"A policy of NATO enlargement now, we believe, would be a strategic error. Normally when military alliances enlarge it is to gain strength themselves, it is not to assume new strategic liabilities."

He also called Moscow's reaction "disproportionately strong," saying the spread of its army throughout Georgia was "unjustified" and Russia's "bad temper" was now "almost an instrument of its foreign policy".

IISS Russia expert Oksana Antonenko said the European Union's mediation showed it had the potential to become "a genuine player in the Caucasus" -- though it was lucky France held the EU presidency during the Georgia crisis.

Chipman added that it was not a "wise policy" for NATO to push for Ukrainian membership while the population was split on the issue.

The IISS found that "significant progress" had been made in Iraq in 2008, but to make it permanent, the ruling elite needed to find ways to compromise on political and revenue issues without resorting to violence.

Attention was migrating away from Iraq to Afghanistan and the worsening situation on the Pakistan border, Chipman said.

New Pakistani President Ali Asif Zardari had to make fighting terrorism and Islamist militancy there his top priority, though the army remains unwilling or unable to deal with the resurgent Taliban, he said.

Zardari "will need to balance the conflicting interests of growing US pressure for military strikes in the tribal areas with the Pakistani army's decreasing tolerance for such attacks" -- which could place the government at risk, Chipman explained.

Meanwhile diplomatic efforts to stem the nuclear proliferation challenges posed by Iran and North Korea are both deadlocked, he said.

North Korea last month stopped disabling its nuclear plants, which it agreed to do under a six-nation disarmament deal, and is taking initial steps to restart its plutonium-producing nuclear reactor.

"It will take North Korea less than one year to undo the steps that up until August it was taking to disable its declared nuclear facilities," said Chipman.

"Uncertainty about the health of North Korean leader Kim Jong-Il solidifies the stalemate that is likely to continue at least until a new US president takes office," he added.

Washington's individual share of global power was in relative decline but the United States retains the most impact on global stability, the IISS found.

Its prospective partners in Europe, the Middle East and Asia need to be more assertive in developing initiatives which Washington could comfortably join.

"The quality of these initiatives will determine whether the post-unipolar moment will be more or less good for international security."

Related Links



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Analysis: Georgia was not on their minds
Geneva, Switzerland (UPI) Sep 17, 2008
Of course, the famous song written by Stuart Gorrell and Hoagy Carmichael refers to the U.S. state of Georgia, not the republic. Regardless, Georgia (the Republic of) should have been on the minds of Western intelligence services -- and not least on the mind of U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, whose expertise is in Soviet affairs. Yet neither she nor the combined Western intelligence agencies were able to foresee Georgia's move into Abkhazia and South Ossetia, nor were they able to predict Russia's response, nor could they foresee that the former Cold War foes are on the brink of a new Cold War. Then again, neither did they predict the sudden collapse of the Soviet Empire.







  • Australia denies China blocking uranium to India
  • Singh to visit US Sept 25
  • India nears nuclear pacts with France, Russia: govt
  • White House sends India nuclear deal to Congress

  • UN chief appoints two new special envoys on climate change
  • Warming World In Range Of Dangerous Consequences
  • Cornell Announces Its First Greenhouse Gas Inventory
  • Sinking feeling: Hot year damages carbon uptake by plants

  • China must probe delays in uncovering milk-scandal: WHO
  • Scientists Behind Doomsday Seed Vault Ready Crops For Climate Change
  • Sowing A Future For Peas
  • Saltwater Solution To Save Crops

  • Swashbuckling Scientists Discover Northern Vents
  • Over 100 New Sharks And Rays Classified
  • Luck Gave Dinosaurs An Edge
  • How Corals Adapt To Day And Night

  • Grant For Eco-Friendly Rocket Engine
  • College Students Develop Rocket Motors In Tamil Nadu
  • US marks Ares milestone in next chapter of manned space flight
  • Pratt And Whitney Rocketdyne To Further Test J-2X

  • Nuclear Power In Space - Part 2
  • Outside View: Nuclear future in space
  • Nuclear Power In Space

  • Kopernikus, Observing Our Planet For A Safer World
  • Hurricane Ike Larger, Eyeing Landfall Early Saturday in Texas
  • QuikScat's Recent View Of Arctic Sea Ice
  • GMES Under The Spotlight In France

  • Australian company launches 3D Internet tool
  • NASA Uses Commercial Microgravity Flight Services For First Time
  • LockMart Demos New Radiator Tech For TSAT Program
  • UK-DMC Satellite First To Transfer Sensor Data Using Bundle Protocol

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement