Solar Energy News  
US Debates Response To Chinese Anti-Satellite Test

Michael Pillsbury - consultant to the Pentagon
by Malcolm Brown
Washington, DC (VOA) Feb 16, 2007
China's recent test of an anti-satellite system has ignited debate in Washington about how the United States should respond. The U.S. government has already indicated that it is reconsidering future civil space cooperation with China. Beijing's actions also have revived arguments about how far the U.S. military should be allowed to go in its use of space.

A driver plots a route through the streets of Washington, D.C., guided by the constellation of satellites in the Global Positioning System. It is just one illustration of America's growing dependence on space-based hardware.

At the administrative headquarters of the world's largest commercial satellite operator, Intelsat, there is concern about the space debris created by China's deliberate destruction of one of its own satellites.

Richard DalBello is Intelsat's vice president for government relations. "The space environment is a principal concern of ours," he says. "It is a precious commodity. It is an irreplaceable commodity. It is where we have done business successfully for over 40 years and we hope to do it for many more multiples of that."

With the United States heavily reliant on satellites for civilian and military uses, there is wide concern in the U.S. about China's test.

Despite repeated Chinese statements to the contrary, some U.S. defense analysts say the test reflects China's determination to develop space weapons as a way to challenge U.S. military superiority.

Michael Pillsbury is a consultant to the Pentagon and the author of a recent report on China's intentions in space. "The Chinese have been writing for 10 years now about how, if they could blind another country in a crisis, they can win a war which otherwise their forces. their ships, tanks and planes, would be unable to win," says Pillsbury.

Another school of thought, while still condemning China, argues that the White House's refusal to negotiate a treaty banning space weapons is partly to blame.

Arms control advocates, such as Theresa Hitchens at the independent Center for Defense Information, are calling on the U.S. government to reconsider and to start talking. "At least at a minimum we ought to be discussing with other nations, including China, outlining what behaviors are acceptable and what behaviors are unacceptable in space. Certainly the deliberate creation of space debris, through weapons testing, is unacceptable behavior," says Hitchens. "It threatens everyone."

President Bush updated U.S. policy last year by authorizing a new National Space Policy document. It says that the United States is "committed to the use of outer space by all nations for peaceful purposes and for the benefit of all humanity." It also asserts America's right to use space for "defense and intelligence-related activities in pursuit of national interests."

U.S. officials now want to get a clearer sense of Beijing's space plans. State Department spokesman Sean McCormack called for greater openness from the Chinese.

"The bottom line is we encourage them to be more forthcoming and transparent with respect to not only this test but also their space programs," he said from the State Department. "It has been a continuing topic for us, as well as others in the region, to encourage the Chinese to become more transparent in terms of their military spending and their military programs."

Without clarity from Beijing, U.S. government officials have briefed American lawmakers about the Chinese test in a closed-door session.

One senior senator believes that China's actions bolster his argument that the U.S. should pursue military capabilities in space. Jon Kyl of Arizona addressed the issue during a speech to the Heritage Foundation, a conservative Washington think tank. "If targeting an adversary's satellites allows our military to achieve victory more quickly or at a lower cost in blood, such attacks must be considered. The Chinese seem to understand this point much better than we do."

Since the Chinese test, that sort of hawkish argument is widely expected to receive increased attention on Capitol Hill and beyond.

Source: Voice of America

Related Links
Military Space News at SpaceWar.com
Military Space News at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


China And Russia Clash With US Over Space Weapons Treaty
Washington (VOA) Feb 15, 2007
China and Russia clashed with the United States Tuesday over a proposal to the United Nations Conference on Disarmament to create a treaty on space weapons. During a meeting of the conference in Geneva Tuesday, Beijing and Moscow voiced their opposition to the U.S. refusal to sign a treaty banning space weapons, and warned that it could lead to an arms race in space.







  • Russia Pins Energy Hopes On New Nuclear Monopoly
  • Britain Forced To Rethink Nuclear Power Plans
  • Russia Set To Launch First Unit Of NPP In India In 2008
  • Finland's President Drawn Into Australian Nuclear Debate

  • In Chilly Washington Global Warming Gets New Airing
  • Blair Wants New Climate Change Deal Before Exit
  • US Offered Lucrative Lure Of Global Carbon Trading
  • Scientists To Focus On Climate Change And Energy At AAAS Meeting

  • Roses Are Red But Chocolate Can Be Green
  • Architectural Plan Revealed Of Doomsday Arctic Seed Vault
  • Doomsday Vault Will Protect Millions Of Seeds
  • Canadian Farmer On Global Crusade Against GM Seeds

  • Researchers Untangle Nature Of Regressive Evolution In Cavefish
  • The Chimpanzee Stone Age
  • World Shark Attacks Rise Slightly But Continue Long-Term Dip
  • Illegal Wildlife Trade In China Undiminished By Bans And Health Threats

  • NASA Solicits Ideas For Constellation Ground Work
  • New Space Technology Provides Less Shake Rattle And Roll
  • DemoFlight 2 Launch Update
  • SpaceDev Conducts Hot-Fire Test Of Hybrid Upper Stage Rocket Motor



  • Gascom To Launch 4 Smotr Low-Orbit Remote Sensing Satellites
  • GeoEye Makes Final Debt Payment For The Purchase Of Space Imaging
  • Google Earth To Blur Key India Sites
  • Brazilian Satellite Undergoes Environmental Tests

  • Lockheed Martin Upgrade To Extend Life Of Romanian Radars 15 To 20 Years
  • SpaceDev Starsys Division Tests System For General Dynamics Advanced Information Systems
  • In Tiny Supercooled Clouds Physicists Exchange Light And Matter
  • Liquid Crystals Stabilised

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement