Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Solar Energy News .




POLITICAL ECONOMY
Walker's World: Reforming the tax system
by Martin Walker
Edinburgh, Scotland (UPI) Aug 5, 2013


disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only

Any suggestion that the United States is a heavily taxed country flies in face of the historical evidence.

Federal income and corporate taxes are lower than at any time since 1945. And federal revenues from social insurance payments are lower, as a proportion of gross domestic product, than at any time since 1950.

The Fiscal Year 2012 budget published by the Office for Management and Budget includes Historical Tables that date back to 1945 (Tables 2-3) that are very informative.

In 1952, corporate taxes took 6 percent of GDP. Today they take 2 percent. In 1952, individual income tax took 14 percent of GDP. Today it takes 8 percent. Social insurance payments in 1952 were 16 percent of GDP and today 14 percent.

So the federal tax take in 1952 from these three main areas of revenue were 35 percent of GDP. Today they amount to 24 percent.

Bring the comparisons forward to 1998. In that year, corporate taxes were 2.5 percent of GDP, income taxes were 12 percent and social insurance revenues were 19 percent. That made a total of 33.5 percent of GDP, nearly half as much again as today.

These comparisons are important because tax reform is again under discussion in Washington, with U.S. President Barack Obama proposing to cut the nominal rate of corporate tax. The broad principle is to do so by closing loopholes in a way that would make the reform revenue-neutral while also making it easier for U.S. corporations to bring back profits held from operations overseas.

There are two important cautions to note when assessing OMB data on tax revenues as a share of GDP. The first is that the Great Recession that began in 2007 started to reduce overall GDP, provoking lots of bankruptcies and biting sharply into federal revenues. The banks were making no profits and the big auto firms like General Motors were taking losses so they weren't contributing to the federal tax take.

The second cautionary factor is that the way GDP is measured is subject to change. Last week, the Bureau of Economic Analysis, which calculates the GDP, released new figures that showed the overall U.S. economy to be about 3 percent larger than it had officially been a few weeks ago.

How did this happen? They changed the way they measure GDP.

Essentially, they decided that much more of the time and effort and resources spent in research and development should be counted as investment, particularly in areas like the arts. So the money spent in developing a Hollywood movie, or the effort that an artist puts into writing and orchestrating a song, or that a novelist puts into writing a manuscript, should be measured as investment.

"A lot of this is about intangibles and intellectual property becoming a much more important component of GDP, our trade, our competiveness. And it's essential we get a better handle on it," says BEA Director Steve Landefeld.

In the past, research and development by business was treated as intermediate expenditure. Now it will be treated as investment. And research and development by non-profits and non-governmental organizations and by government were treated as consumption. Now they, too, will be treated as investment.

In an information economy, such research and development is becoming more and more important and so these new definitions can have a striking effect on calculations of overall GDP.

They can also, therefore, have an impact on tax revenues, depending how much of a tax deduction is allowed for such research. Since the investment will in the future pay off in terms of revenues when the books, movies, songs or computer programs are sold, it makes sense to tax the revenues then and to sallow tax breaks to encourage that researches that lead to innovation and new products.

But here is the core to the problem. The BEA is trying to reflect in GDP figures the way the economy now operates, with more and more services, more and more information and information technology, and more and more intellectual property. But the tax system is still essentially designed to raise revenues from the way the old industrial economy used to be, when products were goods that could be dropped on your foot. These days, valuable products can exist in cyberspace.

The BEA comes up with these revisions to the way it measures the economy every five years. Fifteen years ago they tried to capture the effect of computers that were becoming cheaper even as they became far more powerful in a way that also increased the statistical value of GDP. Many economists, particularly in Europe, were critical of this new "holistic" system as a kind of statistical sleight of hand.

Since the structure of our modern economy is changing so fundamentally with the Internet and globalization, self-publishing and digital distribution, it is logical to find ways to capture these changes in the way we measure the economy.

It would also be logical to reform the tax system in a way that reflects these changes, particularly a tax system as complex and convoluted as that in the United States. The Internal Revenue Service's own Taxpayer Advocate estimates that Americans spend 6 billion hours filing their tax returns at a total cost of $168 billion.

And that brings us back to the figures at the start of this column, and the share of GDP taken by the federal government for income and corporate taxes and social insurance.

Bottom line: The take is a lot less than it used to be.

.


Related Links
The Economy






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








POLITICAL ECONOMY
Outside View: Obama, GOP make no sense on taxes and spending
College Park, Md. (UPI) Aug 5, 2013
Republicans are from Venus and U.S. President Barack Obama is from Mars. Nothing better demonstrates this than their stances on taxes, spending and jobs. Obama wants to reform corporate taxes - shut loopholes, impose a mandatory levy on profits earned abroad and lower rates overall - but to also raise additional revenue to fund his jobs initiatives. The corporate tax code is to ... read more


POLITICAL ECONOMY
Microbial Who-Done-It For Biofuels

Microorganisms found in salt flats could offer new path to green hydrogen fuel

CSU researchers explore creating biofuels through photosynthesis

Drought response identified in potential biofuel plant

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Robot turning Japanese children into master calligraphers

ISS Astronauts Remotely Control Planetary Rover From Space

Spain museum uses robot to help restore works

Chips that mimic the brain

POLITICAL ECONOMY
SOWITEC Mexico - strengthening its permitted project pipeline

Sky Harvest To Acquire Vertical Axis Wind Turbine Technology And Manufacturing Facilities

Wind Energy: Components Certification Helps Reduce Costs

Wind power does not strongly affect greater prairie chickens

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Car-hacking researchers hope to wake up auto industry

BMW takes 'great leap forward' into electric car market

Hydrogen cars quickened by Copenhagen chemists

Toyota, Ford end hybrid partnership

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Moniz addresses emissions, natural gas and exports

Major west-to-east oil pipeline proposed in Canada

Oil prices edge higher on upbeat Chinese economic data

Oil prices rise on US, China data

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Taiwan lawmakers scuffle over planned nuclear plant

TEPCO returns to profit on bailout, rate hikes

Japan nuclear watchdog to beef up Fukushima monitoring

Nuke experts blast Fukushima operator over leaks

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Spanish ministers meet with energy investors on market reforms

Americans continue to use more renewable energy sources

Sweden's Vattenfall hit by $4.6-bn charge as energy demand plunges

Six Tech Advancements Changing the Fossil Fuels Game

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Wasps being used to fight tree disease

Drought making trees more susceptible to dying in forest fires

7 arrested in murder of Costa Rican environmentalist

Tropical Ecosystems Boost Carbon Dioxide as Temperatures Rise




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement