Solar Energy News  
War Lessons Revive Old Ideas

Gabi Ashkenazi, designated as the Israel Defense Forces's next chief of general staff
by Joshua Brilliant
UPI Israel Correspondent
Tel Aviv (UPI) Jan 29, 2007
Tough-looking, no-nonsense infantryman Gabi Ashkenazi, designated as the military's next chief of general staff, has a formidable task ahead: He will have to prepare the military for a wide range of threats from a nuclear Iran to a suicide bomber trying to leave Nablus; and in doing so he will have to correct strategies proven wrong in the last Lebanon War.

Ashkenazi had been in the army until 2005 when the air force's Dani Halutz won the race for chief of general staff. Ashkenazi replaced his olive green fatigues with dark blue business suits and is now the Defense Ministry's director general. Last week Halutz resigned and in about a fortnight Ashkenazi is going to be lieutenant general.

"He is going to return the IDF (Israel Defense Forces) to its basic values," predicted retired Maj. Gen. Uri Saguy, who had been one of Ashkenazi's commanders.

Saguy put his finger on one of the basic problems that last summer's war in Lebanon exposed. The military developed a concept that did not work.

Analysts maintained the Arabs realized they cannot beat Israel in a conventional war, so such wars are over. Rockets, possibly carrying weapons of mass destruction, are the major threat. That, and guerrilla type warfare.

The military thought of "shaping (the enemy's) consciousness" and using "levers and effects." When it wanted to warn Syria not to back Hezbollah, is sent fighter planes over President Bashar Assad's home in Latakiya, in northern Syria. The message was: beware.

Such thinking also affected the way the war was run. The Ha'aretz newspaper Tuesday published excerpts from General Staff debates at that time.

Bint Jbail is a Muslim-Shiite southern Lebanese town where Hezbollah's leader Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah delivered a victory speech in May 2000 upon Israel's evacuation of southern Lebanon. Nasrallah described Israel as a flimsy spider web.

Shortly after Hezbollah sparked the summer's fighting by kidnapping two Israeli soldiers, the head of the Ground Forces Command Maj. Gen. Benny Gantz recommended Israel "take the place apart." It is a Muslim-Shiite town, he noted.

The Head of the Northern Command Maj. Gen. Udi Adam and Deputy Chief of General Staff Maj. Gen. Moshe Kaplinsky maintained there was no tactical military significance to occupying Bint Jbail. "It has a symbolic significance," Kaplinsky said.

The military honed the air force, Israel's strategic long range arm, and made strides in fighting the Palestinian militants. Since 2003 Israel has been foiling more and more planned suicide bombings. In 2003 it foiled 83 percent and last year 95.

Hezbollah's quiet buildup was relegated "to the fringes of the intelligence briefings," the chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Zahi Hanegbi, told a Herzliya conference.

The new ideas and budget cuts led to closing tank units and curtailing training exercises. Commanders sat behind plasma screen directing small units in policing the occupied territories. They lacked experience in managing large formations.

The war was a wake-up call and one of the main lessons was to dump the "levers and effects strategy." Instead of trying to influence the enemy's consciousness, "you've got to lick the enemy with physical force," Hanegbi told United Press International. Arab belief that Hezbollah won the war, despite some 1,000 dead and extensive material damage, seemed to convince Israelis they do not understand the Arab mind.

Right after the war the army began drawing new plans and is now implementing some of them. It is rebuilding units that were dismantled and has stepped up training.

Brig. Gen. Udi Dekel, who heads the Strategic unit in GHQ's Planning Directorate, told the Herzliya conference the long term plans talk of four pillars.

One is to strengthen Israel's early warning capabilities from providing a strategic warning over Iran's nuclear capabilities to very specific warnings about an individual suicide bomber. It will seek more intelligence in order to launch pin-point attacks, for example on Hezbollah's hidden rockets. Hezbollah had concealed some of them so well that soldiers found them only when stepping on them, a military source said.

The second goal is to strengthen deterrence by demonstrating readiness to use the force. Fewer 'effects' and more coping with threats in order to neutralize them, Dekel said.

If deterrence fails, the army should lick the enemy using also ground forces, combining movement and accurate fire. The air force failed to stop the short range rocket attacks. The soldiers on the ground did. During the Lebanon war the army was reluctant to order divisional attacks and when it did so, it was too late because a cease-fire went into effect. The army will also have to develop capabilities to fight in civilian populated areas since guerrillas hide there, Dekel said. That was the third leg of the new plan.

The fourth element will focus on active defense against rocket attacks. Israel tended to ignore the short range rockets' potential. It did not stop Hezbollah from deploying more than 10,000 rockets in southern Lebanon.

The war proved that a steady attack on civilian targets, even with crude missiles, has a strategic effect. Most of northern Israel was paralyzed during the war as 40 civilians were killed and some 2,400 were wounded.

"We need a capability to intercept rockets," said Dekel. The cost of intercepting a Scud was 10 times the price of the Scud itself and knocking out short range rockets will require an even bigger investment, he said.

Source: United Press International

Related Links
Your World At War



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Saudi-Iran Clash Via Lebanese
Washington (UPI) Jan 25, 2007
The war between Sunnis and Shiites that began several centuries ago in Mesopotamia was re-ignited in modern Iraq following the U.S. invasion. More recently it has spread to Lebanon bringing that country dangerously close to the precipice of civil war one more time.







  • Israel Should Develop Nuclear Energy
  • General Electric Interested In Lithuania Nuclear Power Plant Project
  • Putin Promises India More Nuclear Power
  • Russia And India To Sign Deal On Building NPPs

  • All Eyes On Scientists As Climate Summit Opens
  • Melting Glaciers Show Climate Change Speeding Up
  • Climate Scientists Set To Serve Up A Slab Of Bad News
  • Business World Urges Governments To Be Bolder On Climate Change

  • Critics Say Global Plan To Save Tuna Stocks Not Enough
  • British Food Retailers Carving Out Green Future
  • Escapes From Norway's Fish Farms Threaten Wild Salmon
  • Conservationists Meet To Avert Feared Tuna Extinction

  • Darwin's Bulldog And The Time Machine
  • Does Evolution Select For Faster Evolvers
  • Woman "Saved Husband's Life" In Lion Attack
  • Biologist Clair Ting Explores Photosynthetic Apparatus

  • Test Flights Of Angara Boosters To Start In 2010
  • Researchers Create New Class Of Compounds
  • India Delays Cryogenic Rocket Engine Test Two Weeks
  • India To Conduct Full-Duration Cryogenic Stage Test



  • First Thai Observation Satellite To Be Orbited In October
  • Space Technology Can Help Ailing Agri Sector: Kasturirangan
  • New Sensor To Be A Boon To Astronomers
  • Russia's Putin, India Call For 'Weapons Free' Space

  • Raytheon Antennas Will Perform More Than Twice Design Life
  • Terminal High Altitude Area Defense Radar Tested In Integrated Flight
  • Surprising Transition Observed When Flowing Grains Become Too Jam Packed To Move
  • Harnessing Static To Improve Wireless Signals

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement